So I’ve been on the fence about whether or not to do something like this. Pop music is one of the biggest constants in my life – and the only element of pop culture that consistently holds my attention. I’m also a critical type of dude, so I catalog stuff like this as it happens. That said, classifying music (or anything else) by dividing it into decades is kind of stupid and completely arbitrary – why, exactly, would something made in 2000 have more in common with something made in 2009 than something made in 1999? Moreover, the concept of “best” seems totally meaningless with a period of time so large and a pool of music so diverse – could Animal Collective, for example, truly be either better OR worse than Britney Spears? Aren’t they kind of on different pages?
Oh but what the hell? This is fun. I’m drawn to stuff like this. I’m sure that in five years I’ll have a far better perspective, but it’s better to get into the fray while the getting is good. I’ll say, though, that this list is intentionally not comprehensive. No sense in overdoing.
I tried to not write too much about anything.
Bands:
Liars. Beginning as the most punishing and fierce of the initial wave of “dance punkers” at the beginning of the decade, Liars has made a habit of taking dramatic stylistic turns with each subsequent record. They’re always weird – particularly on their middle two albums, They Were Wrong, So We Drowned and Drum’s Not Dead.
Spoon. Spoon is a band that had a distinct forward trajectory throughout the decade. Kill the Moonlight might be the most enjoyable record they’ve made from start to finish, but as the years progressed their sound deepened and became more defined, culminating with the mature Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga.
the Strokes. I like Room on Fire more than I like Is This It? But I like all their records.
—
Solo Performers
Justin Timberlake. At the beginning of the decade, he was kind of famous as the most visible member of *N SYNC and as Britney Spears’ boyfriend. Most guys would be fat and drunk on a reality TV show right now, but Timberlake parlayed those opportunities into a full-fledged respectable career. Pre-dating “Hey ya!” by several months, “Rock Your Body” was the track that softened me up for the eventual takeover of pop music in my brainspace during the mid-2000s.
David Byrne. What a great man! People want Talking Heads to reunite, but that’s in the past. Not to slag on the others, but why would Byrne want to reunite when he’s so vital on his own (or with Brian Eno, as on Everything That Happens)?
Lil’ Wayne. I’m seldom into rappers – the last last guy I really got behind was Ol’ Dirty Bastard, and he’s been dead for a while. But Wayne’s got me. He can sing. He’s musical. Now that he’s got the autotune, he uses it as an instrument unto itself. He doesn’t sound like anyone else.
—
Albums
Belle & Sebastian: The Life Pursuit. Oh my god, this one is so good. This is a runaway winner for my favorite album of the decade. I had forgotten about this band for maybe five full years before it started getting blasted at my house back at Alvarado Street and I was in love immediately. The band, always personal and charming, has blossomed into a full-on confident pop group that somehow holds on to its initial appeal. The songs are simple, but repeated listens are continually rewarding.
Animal Collective: Merriweather Post Pavilion. Despite having a million opportunities, I never listened to Animal Collective aside from one or two occasions until I got Merriweather Post Pavilion. Having not closely monitored their development, I was pretty shocked at the fully-formed and completely unique world that exists here. This is a beautiful record.
Sally Shapiro: Disco Romance. Annie seduced me in 2005, and Anniemal definitely paved the way in my palette for this album. I can relate better to Sally, though, and when I listen to this album I feel like it’s just walking with me, in a way. Does that make any sense?
Godspeed You Black Emperor: Lift Yr. Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven. An early favorite, and one to which I can’t help but return pretty regularly. Back in the day people called stuff like this “post-rock” and that title seems really silly right now. It’s just extended apocalyptic instrumental jammy time with rock instruments.
the Shins: Oh, Inverted World. Speaking of early favorites that I can’t seem to shake…
—
Songs
Outkast: “Hey ya!” Oh man, remember when this jam was current and you could hear it everywhere you went and people from all walks of life would dance like crazy as soon as they heard Andre go “1, 2, 3, 4!”? It didn’t matter if that shit came on in a Kmart or a funeral, people would be writhing in the aisles. At least that’s how I remember it…
Destiny’s Child: “Soldier (featuring TI and Lil’ Wayne).”
Hot Chip: “Ready for the Floor.”
Björk: “Cvalda.”
Hecuba: “Extra Connection.”
The Pains of Being Pure at Heart: “Young Adult Friction.”
Radiohead: “There There.”
Feist: “1,2,3,4.”
Vampire Weekend: “M79.”
Smashing Pumpkins: “Tarantula.”
Kylie Minogue: “Can’t Get You Out of My Head.”
Arcade Fire: “Keep the Car Running.”
The Very Best: “Tengazako.”